From Excalibur to the Boardroom –Board Evaluation Best Practices in the United Kingdom vs the United States

What is a board evaluation? Why is it important? What are the board evaluation practices in the UK vs the US?

The board’s performance evaluation is akin to the sharpening of a finely crafted sword, honed to perfection in the crucible of corporate governance. This vital process is globally recognized as the touchstone for enhancing board effectiveness. Like the legendary British Excalibur (a legendary sword in Arthurian mythology, known for its extraordinary power and symbolism), an effective performance evaluation helps the board, committees, and individual directors wield their full potential, forging a strong leadership culture, clarifying the diverse roles of the knights at the round table, bolstering communication within the ranks, and fostering seamless teamwork. In this way, decision-making processes are refined, and the efficiency of board operations is propelled to new heights.

In the United Kingdom, the renowned Cadbury Report of 1992 heralded a new era in corporate governance, providing a framework that has since become a beacon for countries around the world. In comparison, the United States has developed its distinct approach to corporate governance, with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 serving as a lighthouse amidst the stormy seas of financial scandals. Performance evaluation is a cornerstone in both these models, shaping boards into powerful engines of corporate progress.

The UK’s Financial Reporting Council (FRC), much like a wise architect, has laid the foundation for an effective board evaluation process through its UK Corporate Governance Code. Meanwhile, the US, a veritable melting pot of business practices, has given rise to a multitude of diverse evaluation techniques. As the British and American landscapes of corporate governance continue to evolve, both nations strive to transform their boards into well-oiled machines, ready to conquer the challenges of the ever-changing business world.

A case study that exemplifies the importance of board evaluation is the remarkable turnaround of British supermarket giant Tesco. After facing a decline in market share and profitability, Tesco’s board underwent a comprehensive evaluation, resulting in a renewed focus on its core business and a streamlined approach to decision-making. This metamorphosis exemplifies how board evaluation can breathe new life into a company, much like the mythical phoenix rising from the ashes.

The Institute, acting as a master craftsman, has brought forth a revised publication on board performance evaluation. Drawing inspiration from the best practices of both the UK and the US, this publication is a treasure trove of wisdom, guiding boards through the labyrinth of evaluation methodologies, legal frameworks, and post-evaluation activities. It serves as a map to navigate the complex world of board evaluation, providing parameters, sample models, and insights into the latest trends and practices.

In conclusion, the power of board performance evaluation cannot be overstated. Like the legendary King Arthur uniting the disparate tribes of Britain under a common banner, board evaluation has the potential to harmonize corporate governance across the globe. By harnessing the best practices from the United Kingdom and the United States, we can ensure that boards are equipped to lead their organizations toward success, fulfilling their destinies as champions of good governance.

Copyright Summit Consulting Ltd 2023. All rights reserved.

Share this



Related Articles

Focus on enjoying the journey, not the destination

#mindspark There is always someone better. Relax. And move at your own pace. When I got a job at EY as an auditor, then

The crime period: are you ready?

This is the time of the year when the need to have cash on you is more important than ever. As you try to

Spyware on the rise – be careful of mobile gadget gifts

We like to gift or be gifted. Sometimes, such devices have installed spyware that monitors all your activities on the phone. Marriages have broken

Cyber security – managing a crisis in the digital era

Information security and system resilience are strategic issues for every business, with media reports of security breaches in businesses, government agencies and other organisations

About Author