Start typing to search the whole website.

Summit Consulting Ltd
Home
Password Strength Checker Cyber Risk Quick Check Are You Safe Online? Are You Cyber Secure? AML Compliance Quiz Data Privacy and Protection Act Quiz Financial IQ Quiz Culture Audit MS Office & Excel Skills Quiz Risk Management Self-Assessment IFRS 9 Adoption Questionnaire 10-Minute Leadership Presence Self-Assessment Board Diversity Assessment Tool MFA Authentication Quiz Benford Analysis Tool Internal Audit Survey BCP / DR Survey Insurance Fraud Policy Questionnaire Fraud Management Survey Strategy Implementation Effectiveness Survey Boardtool Resources 7 Tools Board Book iShield 360 Project FRONTLINE Report Summit Weekly Newsletters Uganda Banking Report The Human Rights Enforcement Act 2019: A Guide Managing Board Affairs in a New Era Barriers to Effective Strategy Execution 8 Strategies to Overcome Sales Rejections Board Evaluation Tool SummitEthical Board Assessment Tool Board Effectiveness Template Executive Ownership Matrix Chair-CEO Gap Framework The 5-Fit Test for Directors The Promotion Readiness Grid The Accountability Chain The Alignment Grid The Trench Leadership Index The Secretary Power Grid Future Director Matrix Mr Strategy's Compass Card Template Mr Strategy's Culture Health Check Tool The Chair Navigation Compass The Fear Filter Tool Leadership Readiness Assessment Scorecard ERM Accountability Map Template Key Risk Indicator (KRI) Template ICT Asset Register Template Digital Risk Oversight Radar Template Enterprise Risk Management Framework and Internal Audit Program Audit Committee Briefing Report Template Internal Audit Board Briefing Template Fraud Reporting Register Template AI and Machine Learning Risk Governance Assessment Tool Strategic Foresight Audit Tool EXCO Execution Grid SIEM Tool Assessment Criteria Cybersecurity Assessment Tool (ISO 27001 and NIST) iShield 360: Multi-Factor Authentication Tools iShield 360 Cybersecurity Risk Assessment Template iShield 360: DLP System Tool Phishing Awareness Guide Password Security Checklist Black Box Penetration Testing Checklist Penetration Testing Scoping Questionnaire Cyberattack Incident Response Plan (CIRP) Template End-of-session Leadership Transition Evaluation SOC Assessment Survey Cybersecurity Survey Questionnaire IFRS9 Adoption Questionnaire
Insights
Talk to us
+256 782 610333 support@summitcl.com

Six years ago, around 2019, while facilitating a board retreat for a regional insurance player, I posed a simple question to the directors: “How do you know when the board doing a good job?” One director replied, “We hold quarterly meetings on time.” Another director chimed in, “Our audit reports are clean.” And then another, “We have more than 80% meeting attendance rate.” They thought they had nailed it. I thought they were joking. They weren’t.

And that’s the problem.

Most board evaluations are superficial at best and performative at worst. They focus on compliance tick-boxes attendance, timely submissions, and committee structure. What they miss is the board’s actual impact on business outcomes. Governance has become a theatre. Everyone plays their part, and no one checks if the script is working. Do you have a board scorecard? Many boards do not! Do you have a board’s risk appetite? The answer is usually no! How do you drive a car with a revving but no dashboard to tell you the speed at which you are driving? How do you have a car without breaking system?

The insurance board I referenced earlier had overseen three failed strategy rollouts, rising claims ratios, and a ballooning cost base. But their evaluation? “Board functioning is satisfactory.” Why? Because no one asked: Did we challenge management enough? Did we steer strategy or simply nod through presentations?

To fix this, you start with the right diagnosis like any competent doctor. You don’t start treatment before the scan. A proper board review asks penetrating questions about value addition. Not just “Did we have a retreat?” but “Did we translate the retreat insights into strategic pivots?”

advanced divider

" Most board evaluations are superficial at best and performative at worst ”

Tweet
advanced divider

Take these instead:

a) What three decisions in the last 12 months did the board influence that materially changed our market position?
b) How did we respond to signals of market disruption before our competitors did?
c) What strategic assumptions did we last challenge that led to a course correction
?

Boards must shift from ritual to relevance.

Here’s the leadership challenge: Most boards don’t want real feedback because real feedback creates discomfort. And leaders fear discomfort more than poor performance.

Leadership tool

Implement a “Board Impact Tracker.” After every meeting, each board member records one decision that added measurable value and one that didn’t. Review quarterly. If you can’t name a decision that mattered, your board didn’t govern. It just convened.

In the insurance board I mentioned, we introduced this tracker. Three directors resigned within six months voluntarily. The remaining ones got sharper, more involved, and finally asked the CEO for a strategy that could scale, not survive. Today, they’ve expanded regionally, with three consecutive profitable years.

Evaluate performance, yes. But only if you’re brave enough to change what you find. Otherwise, save the time. And the ink.

This tracker is not a tick-box exercise. It’s a mirror. The best boards I’ve worked with in agriculture value chains, for instance, used it quarterly and performance spiked not just in boardroom decorum, but in results on the ground. If your board isn’t tracking impact this way, it’s navigating with a blindfold

0 comments

Leave a comment

Keep reading

More from Summit Consulting.