Effective boards build a culture that delivers, not just one that looks good on paper

Effective boards build a culture that delivers, not just one that looks good on paper

Let’s get straight to it. Most boards are focused on the wrong things. Endless discussions on policies, new frameworks, and best practices. But guess what? A board can have perfect policies and still fail. Why? Because “culture eats policy for breakfast”, to paraphrase the Leadership Guru Michael Porter.

The real secret is to embrace culture, not compliance.

In our boardrooms, we love to throw around words like “governance” and “oversight.” It’s the language of safety. It makes us feel like we’re doing our jobs. But the truth is, compliance doesn’t create a high-performance board, culture does.

I have seen boards with all the right boxes ticked: audit committees, risk frameworks, quarterly reports, board evaluations and board diversity. But when it comes down to making tough calls, challenging each other, and having real discussions-it’s total silence. That’s what kills performance, not a lack of policies or charters.

The hard questions we need to ask ourselves

Here’s the reality. A high-performance board doesn’t just follow rules. It challenges assumptions. It fights complacency. It pushes the organization forward even when it’s uncomfortable. So, let’s ask ourselves:

Are we too comfortable with each other?

Great boards aren’t about friendships. They are about productive friction. Directors who challenge each other, who dig deeper when things don’t add up. It’s not about making life easy; it’s about making decisions better.

Do we avoid the elephant in the room?

If we’re not tackling the real issues of poor leadership, market shifts, or failing strategies we are just pretending to do our job. A board that’s afraid to get into the mess is a board that’s failing.

Are we obsessed with processes or with results?

I have seen it time and time again-boards that spend more time perfecting the minutes than thinking about strategy. Here’s the truth: nobody cares if the minutes are perfect when the organization is bleeding money. Focus on results, not rituals.

In our boardrooms, we love to throw around words like “governance” and “oversight.” It’s the language of safety. It makes us feel like we’re doing our jobs. But the truth is, compliance doesn’t create a high-performance board - culture does.
Mr.Strategy Tweet

Why it matters more here

Let’s not kid ourselves-African challenges are unique. We cannot “copy and paste” global best practices. We operate in markets where regulation can be inconsistent, where business models change rapidly, and where talent retention is a constant battle.

If our board culture doesn’t adapt to this reality, we are doomed. We can’t afford a culture of politeness and groupthink. We need a culture where:

Difficult conversations are encouraged.Don’t worry about hurting feelings; worry about missing opportunities. If you are not willing to challenge the CEO or fellow directors, you’re not doing your job.
Action is valued over analysis paralysis.Boards that spend months reviewing strategy documents but do nothing about poor execution are wasting time. Here, we need to act quickly, not get bogged down in endless debates.

Why do most boards get it wrong?

Most boards think they’re high-performing because they’re busy. They meet regularly, follow the agenda, and review financials. But let’s be honest- being busy isn’t the same as being effective.

A high-performance board is comfortable being uncomfortable. It’s willing to go beyond the data, to ask, “What’s happening on the ground?” It’s not about nodding along; it’s about pushing back when something doesn’t sit right.

My call to action: shake up the culture

We need to change how we operate. Not just how we meet or what we discuss, but how we think. Here’s what I’m asking from each of you:

Start with transparency. Let’s be honest about what’s not working. Whether it’s management, strategy, or even the board itself. We can’t fix what we won’t admit is broken.
Demand tough conversations. If a director isn’t adding value, call it out. If the CEO is sugar-coating the numbers, dig deeper. We’re not here to be liked; we’re here to lead.
Shift focus to impact. Let’s measure ourselves not by how many meetings we attend, but by the impact of our decisions. Did we drive real change? Did we ask the hard questions? Did we challenge the status quo?

Leadership is uncomfortable, and that’s how it should be

I know this might sound harsh, but the reality is harsh. In Africa, where business environments are tough and markets can shift overnight, we don’t have the luxury of playing it safe. We need to create a board culture that’s built for action, not just compliance.

If we can do that, we’ll not only survive-we will thrive. But it starts with each of us being willing to get uncomfortable, get real, and get results.

Let’s lead like we mean it.