Start typing to search the whole website.

Summit Consulting Ltd
Home
Password Strength Checker Cyber Risk Quick Check Are You Safe Online? Are You Cyber Secure? AML Compliance Quiz Data Privacy and Protection Act Quiz Financial IQ Quiz Culture Audit MS Office & Excel Skills Quiz Risk Management Self-Assessment IFRS 9 Adoption Questionnaire 10-Minute Leadership Presence Self-Assessment Board Diversity Assessment Tool MFA Authentication Quiz Benford Analysis Tool Internal Audit Survey BCP / DR Survey Insurance Fraud Policy Questionnaire Fraud Management Survey Strategy Implementation Effectiveness Survey Boardtool Resources 7 Tools Board Book iShield 360 Project FRONTLINE Report Summit Weekly Newsletters Uganda Banking Report The Human Rights Enforcement Act 2019: A Guide Managing Board Affairs in a New Era Barriers to Effective Strategy Execution 8 Strategies to Overcome Sales Rejections Board Evaluation Tool SummitEthical Board Assessment Tool Board Effectiveness Template Executive Ownership Matrix Chair-CEO Gap Framework The 5-Fit Test for Directors The Promotion Readiness Grid The Accountability Chain The Alignment Grid The Trench Leadership Index The Secretary Power Grid Future Director Matrix Mr Strategy's Compass Card Template Mr Strategy's Culture Health Check Tool The Chair Navigation Compass The Fear Filter Tool Leadership Readiness Assessment Scorecard ERM Accountability Map Template Key Risk Indicator (KRI) Template ICT Asset Register Template Digital Risk Oversight Radar Template Enterprise Risk Management Framework and Internal Audit Program Audit Committee Briefing Report Template Internal Audit Board Briefing Template Fraud Reporting Register Template AI and Machine Learning Risk Governance Assessment Tool Strategic Foresight Audit Tool EXCO Execution Grid SIEM Tool Assessment Criteria Cybersecurity Assessment Tool (ISO 27001 and NIST) iShield 360: Multi-Factor Authentication Tools iShield 360 Cybersecurity Risk Assessment Template iShield 360: DLP System Tool Phishing Awareness Guide Password Security Checklist Black Box Penetration Testing Checklist Penetration Testing Scoping Questionnaire Cyberattack Incident Response Plan (CIRP) Template End-of-session Leadership Transition Evaluation SOC Assessment Survey Cybersecurity Survey Questionnaire IFRS9 Adoption Questionnaire
Insights
Talk to us
+256 782 610333 support@summitcl.com

For the last ten years, since Institute of Forensics and ICT Security (www.forensicsinstitute.org) started fraud awareness initiative, I have visited several organisations and met with so many CEOs and top managers in the region.

Most of the leaders don’t want to acknowledge the extent of the fraud problem within their organisations.

Yet the statistics are clear:

“A typical organisation loses 5% of its annual revenues to fraud each year”, Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, Report To The Nations, 2012. 

Applied to the annual gross revenue of your organisation, the total annual loss to fraud is big. Yet, this is where the problem starts. Few, if any, organisations have put in place tools to measure the extent of the fraud problem.

Many times, I have been called to undertake fraud investigations in banks and insurance companies. As investigators, when we start the assignment, the focus goes on who, did what, where, when and how. Fraud is intentional misrepresentation of a material facts, to cause a gain to one party and a loss by another party.

Every day, people are committing fraud. And this is done clandestinely. The total failure by the top leadership to acknowledge fraud as the biggest business risk is a major challenge of managing the fraud risk.

How do you manage a problem you cannot recognise? How do you get proper medical treatment for an ailment you have convinced yourself you don’t have?

At a recent fraud awareness presentation, one of the senior staff told me; “We have not reported any fraud incident since I joined in this company four years ago.” His CEO, looking rather excited that he is a good leader added; “that is a clear testimony that our controls are working. We have zero tolerance for fraud.”

This reveals a lot about the extent of fraud problem in such an organisation.

Business leaders are living in self denial. The people responsible for protecting shareholder value and ensuring business going concern don’t want to acknowledge the biggest threat to their mandate, fraud and corruption.

As a CEO, if my Internal Auditor or the Head of IT told me that we have no reported fraud case since the year started, I would be more worried.

Why?

If an Internal auditor or IT manager or management cannot detect any fraud it is likely the fraudsters are too smarter.

As fraud researchers have put it, “because fraud inherently involves efforts at concealment, many fraud cases will never be detected, and of those that are, the full amount of losses might never be determined or reported. Consequently, any attempt to quantify total occupational fraud losses will be, at best, an estimate.”

Failing to record a fraud case could be a sign of a bigger problem.

All NGOs, telecom companies, banks, insurance companies and government are at a higher risk. The general control environment is weak. In any organisation, all staff are potential fraudsters if three things are present: (i) motive or incentive, (ii) rationalisation and (iii) opportunity. The first two are inherent to every staff. The organisation can control the last one. Because many fraud cases involve collusion and override of controls, if staff decide to commit fraud, they will bypass any internal controls in the system and fraud will go on undetected.

I am often required to register my laptop when accessing most big companies at the security check point. When I ask, why are you registering my ipad, the common answer a security guard gives is “this is the procedure.” People have not been told why controls are in place.

You would expect an answer like “we don’t want you to lose your laptop in our premises and we fail to trace it for you. Or, don’t go inside with an old laptop and exchange it with the company’s brand-new model.” Or “don’t go instead with a new laptop and exchange it with an old one which has company secrets that are invaluable to us.” That would mean that at registration and exit, the security guard is alert and keen on details like laptop serial number, make and model.

Such general lack of appreciation of why certain things/ controls are done is so big when it comes to implementation of controls and systems.

Staff see certain things as burdensome instead of appreciating them for value addition.

© Mustapha B. Mugisa, Mr. Strategy 2019. All rights reserved.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Keep reading

More from Summit Consulting.